"...one of the British goth topacts simply cos we’re not dealing with a band who stole a riff from The Sisters but a duo who are making dark synthpop in where doomy sounds rule..." and "...it’s a shame that bands like them are banned to the underground cos Cauda pavonis simply have made a sound that belongs to the best artists with original ideas can make.".

"...the atmospheric keyboard sounds and the darkly erotic voice of Su Farr determine the course of events." and "Driving Beats and real drums take care of the danceability." and "...nostalgic sounds which remind one of the beginnings of Gothic music, interwoven with modern Programming so that they always sound fresh and never stale." and "For those for whom Dark music appears to have fallen asleep, a jewel of innovation is to be discovered here."

"...this likeable duo (the "Dark wave Buckaneers") have come up with another strong album."and "Controversial alchemy is an imaginative album, with each track having its own distinct theme." and "...keeps the catchy tunes flowing...".

"Cauda Pavonis prove their worth with this short, but brilliant record." and " Su Farr's assertive voice and the driving rhythms should make it a dancefloor filler." and "This album has very strong songs that should make Cauda Pavonis stars in any just world".

"...found a good resonance in the gothic rock-scene." and "...male & female vocals over gothic rock with synth rhythms, resulting in a sound which is both contemporary and Retro."

"...Controversial Alchemy has been long awaited by the people already touched by the brilliance of Cauda Pavonis." and "...biting gothic vocals that hook you in and won't let you go." and "Controversial Alchemy sees Cauda Pavonis enhancing their reputation..."

"...a post-punk semi electronic band with darkwave touches, or failing that - Adam And The Ants natural successors for their flamboyant imagery, and a theatrical theme..." and "...a welcome breath of fresh air from a world of rip off bands...".

"Cauda Pavonis slash a swashbuckling swathe through the recent glut of EBM wannabees.'Controversial Alchemy' has also got that wonderful diversity that's increasingly rare." and "Almost defying description, Su Farr's incredible vocals swoop and soar, sneer and seduce.".

"...Cauda Pavonis have gone from strength to strength, and 'Controversial Alchemy' will form a welcome addition to your CD collection." and "every track leaves a marked impression, bringing visions of days of grandeur and nights of, well, something a bit more seedy shall we say." and "...a must have album." and "9/10. A complete masterpiece..

"...Cauda Pavonis use real drums (and occasional guitar samples) infusing the music with a bit of rock energy..." and "...definitely worth owning.(4/5)".

"Belting Album."

"...Su Farr has a very strong and charismatic voice..." and "in the vein of good old writing traditions..." and "The whole album is a very pleasant accquantance."